
Phantom has been away for a while. There was a mix up in the accounting and finance office at LondonderryNH.net. After they paid John and Joes salary and EJ’s movie tickets and then helped switch Jack to de-caf , there wasn’t much money left to pay for Phantoms’ dining bills. So again with his own buck Phantom has returned. How opportune to have a restaurant review this Christmas (sorry, Holiday, Hanukikah, Festivas and New Years) season and perhaps try a local place you have driven past but not yet stopped at.
The test of any new restaurant you try is to ask the simple question, would I come back here again? After Phantom and guests first stop a few months back the answer would have been no. We showed up early one Thursday evening before the rush, ordered a few drinks and attempted to place our order. No excuse here but our first two requests for appetizers were met with the same reply, “sorry we are out of that today”. So paying for a few sodas and ice-teas we left.
Wanting to write a review for this local establishment the Phantom decided to give them a second and then a third try as well.
I have been to Halligans Tavern a few times these past few months. I still can’t figure out why exactly. The food is a bit un-even, the staff is a bit gruff in a nice kind of way, but the cozy place kind of grows on you. Located right on 102 in downtown Derry in an old fire house its easy to find, and there is lots of nearby parking too.
Typical tavern/pub menu covers a wide range of items for lunch and dinner from appetizers to desserts. They also feature an events menu. Phantom and guests these last few trips have sampled a variety of items. Lets start with the good. A new item added a few months back drew the Phantoms attention. Irish Potato Skins. The twist here is that the potato shells are topped with juicy corned beef and cheddar. Interesting and with a dab of sour cream quickly devoured. BBQ Flatbread with chicken and cheddar was excellent and much better than many BBQ chicken pizzas phantom has had elsewhere. Good portions and quickly delivered are the other positives for starters at Halligans.
On the down side are the Nachos, order them without the chili. The chili was entirely too “wet” and the soggy mess that resulted was left mostly untouched. On a future visit Phantom will leave off the chili and see how the dish turned out. Chicken Tenders, Wings and two kinds of Calamari round out some other items. I see they removed the Poutine from the menu. Never got a chance to sample my favorite snack from Quebec, as it was never available anyway.
Nothing fancy about either the house or caesar salads. Some vegetables and lettuce massed on a plate served with standard dressings. If you must eat a salad for dinner bring one with you. On the other end the soups are good. Portions a little small but the New England Seafood Chowder and Onion Soup get good marks for hot and a fresh just made taste.
The rest of the menu is broken down to Sandwiches and Wraps; Angus Burgers; and Tavern Favorites. From our several trips skip down to the Favorites section. The meatloaf sandwich disappointed twice. On Phantoms first trip guest ordered the meatloaf that came out dense, dry, cold, flavorless and served on burnt bread. The burnt bread the only part of the dish that had any flavor. On a subsequent trip we gave the meatloaf a second try. It wasn’t any better. The issue we have had with the burgers is not the meat, the roll or the accompanying fries, rings or salads. Basically all good and crafted as solid as one would imagine from any similar menu. The issues is the cooking of the beef.
Phantom likes his meat dead, non-bleeding and very well done. There is a difference between well done and burnt. There is also a difference when items are ordered rare – or medium – or medium rare. The kitchen does not seem to have this cooking of meat to order down to a science yet. So as a helpful reminder if a burger is wanted well – ask for medium. If a medium burger is wanted ask for rare. Not quite sure how to get a rare burger out of the kitchen. Let Phantom know.
Tavern menu, that has been updated twice recently, offers good choices and decent serving sizes. Though the dinner items are a bit overpriced for the portions provided. Value then is just fare. Good marks go to the Marinated Steak tips (though slightly over cooked, see note above). Juicy seared stakes tips with little fat and no observed gristle were served with seasonal vegetables of a mound of hot and creamy mashed potatoes. The Fish and Chips were as expected. Crisp non-greasy pieces of white fish served with fries and good homemade cole slaw. Phantom and guests did try some new items to the menu. The Maple Bourbon Grilled Salmon was well worth the $18 charge. The glaze departed a sweet smoky flavor on moist salmon fillets that were excellently prepared and accompanied with mashed and seasonal vegetables. Equally good and fully devoured by a guest on a recent trip was the Chicken Broccoli Alfredo. Al-dente pasta with chunks of moist chicken bathed in creamy alfredo. As a tavern with an “Irish” themed menu one may be tempted to have the Sheppard’s Pie, as Phantom did. Skip it. Small, dry, and lacking any flavor not worth the $13 charge.
Don’t be afraid to try some of the sides or ask for substitutions. Sweet potato fries were a crunchy yummy sweet switch for regular fries. The hand-made onion rings weren’t bad either.
We haven’t even mentioned the wide selection of beers and drinks available as one would expect at a tavern. We just mentioned them.
All around still not sure why I keep going back. There are still a few items Phantom may want to try. So maybe on your first visit at Halligans’ you will see the Phantom and guests making yet another trip over to Derry for dinner. You will know who the Phantom is, the one not eating the Sheppard’s Pie or Meatloaf sandwich.
On our Fat Phantom five-fork scale………
Service – 4 - Friendly & Gruff
Food – 3 – Avoid the meatloaf
Value – 2.5
Overall – 3.5
The Halligan Tavern is located at 32 West Broadway in downtown Derry.
Visit them at www.halligantavern.com
Images courtesy of The Halligan Tavern





















![[popup] [popup]](http://www.londonderrynh.net/wp-content/plugins/shout-stream/popup.png)







Recent Comments